One of my kegs is currently filled with a great attempt at a Bell's Two Hearted clone, if I do say so myself. My clone turned out really well and is darn close to its inspiration. But the funny thing is I thought it was going to be awful. Nothing went as intended from mash to kegging. I was a bit distracted on brew day. Every Friday night, if the weather is nice, my neighbors gather at my place for a round of driveway drinking. It's just what it sounds like, we set up lawn chairs in my driveway and enjoy good beer. We'll some of them bring wine or cocktails, but all are welcome. It's really just an excuse to chat with the neighbors.
Usually I don't brew on Friday nights, but I my stores were depleted so I was brewing every weekend. I had grain, hops and yeast and nothing else to do, so I fired up my burners. I should have paid more attention to my brew but I got lost in conversation. My mash was too hot and was resting at 160 so I had to add ice. I forgot to look at my watch so I have no idea how long I mashed. It was at least an hour, maybe more like an hour and twenty minutes. I also overheated my sparge water. More like, I nearly boiled it. It was 197 degrees. I added a lot of ice to get it back to 170. The boil was nearly as comical. I added my 60 minutes hops but my timer didn't start. I was going to hop again at 45, but who knows how long it was since the boil started. It was definitely longer than 15 minutes between first and second hoping. The neighborly conversation was great and everyone was curious about my process. I did a great job explaining all-grain brewing, but a poor job of executing it. I wasn't going to hop anymore, just needed to add whirlflock and yeast nutrient. Those went in around the last ten minutes, but it's any one's guess when they went in from the start of the boil. I shut off the burner by the amount of boil-off from my dipstick, I have no idea how long it actually boiled. I forgot to setup my chiller, so the wort sat an extra 5-10 minutes after I killed the flame. I eventually got the chilled wort into a clean carboy and pitched my yeast. Fortunately, nothing was wrong with the yeast.
So my brew day was a mess, but then I changed my procedure for fermenting too. Usually I'll move my beer to a secondary fermenter after 4-7 days, depending on how long fermentation takes. At that point, I also add hops if I'm dry-hopping, which I was. Then I'll age in the secondary for 2 week before kegging. This time, I added hops to the primary after 4 days and never racked it. I just left everything in the primary for ten days then kegged. So I kegged the beer an entire week earlier than I usually do.
You know what? I'm not sure any of it mattered. The beer is good. Really good. My neighbor drives to Kentucky just to buy Two Hearted (sadly, Bell's does not distribute in TN) and he agrees, its a great knock-off. I had a dozen ways to screw up this beer, and it still turned out. So don't worry about ruining your beer. Here's the thing, you're not going to hurt anything if you screw up a batch of homebrew. It's not like making shine at home, you won't kill anybody if you do it wrong. Your beer might taste horrible and folks will make faces and ridicule you, but they won't die. So don't sweat the little "mistakes" because there's a good chance your beer will be fine. If a batch turns out really bad, there's always next time. You can always dump it.
Fyi, here's the recipe I used.
- 10 lbs Domestic 2-Row
- 2 lbs Vienna Malt
- 8 oz C120
- 8 oz Carapils
- 1.25 oz Centennial pellets 10.80% @ 60
- 1.25 oz Centennial pellets 10.80% @ 30
- 2.5 oz Centennial pellets 10.80% @ dry hop (4 days into fermentation, in secondary if using one)
- 1 Whirlflock tablet@ 15
- Wyeast Yeast Nutrient @ 10
Mash per your usual methods. Honestly, I can't tell you how to repeat my mash from that night. 